New York judge rules data sharing for food delivery customers ‘unconstitutional’

A New York City law which requires food delivery companies to share their customer’s data with restaurants has been ruled unconstitutional, according to a report from Reuters.

US District Judge Analisa Torres in Manhattan ruled in favour of DoorDash, Grubhub and Uber Eats, and said the law violated the First Amendment by improperly regulating commercial speech.

New York City passed the law in summer 2021 as a way of helping restaurants recover from the Covid-19 pandemic. According to Reuters, delivery companies needed to provide restaurants with customers' names, delivery addresses, email addresses and phone numbers, as well as order contents.

The delivery companies argued that the law compromised the privacy rights of customers as well as putting their data security at risk. Reuters added that the companies said the practices enabled restaurants to use this data for marketing purposes and could “poach customers away.”

Speaking to Reuters, DoorDash said the decision "rightly recognized how this law would have violated bedrock First Amendment rights of how we protect New Yorkers' data."

Nicholas Paolucci, a spokesman for New York city’s law department, told Reuters that it is currently reviewing the court’s ruling.

National Technology News has reached out to DoorDash, Grubhub and Uber Eats for comment.



Share Story:

Recent Stories


The future-ready CFO: Driving strategic growth and innovation
This National Technology News webinar sponsored by Sage will explore how CFOs can leverage their unique blend of financial acumen, technological savvy, and strategic mindset to foster cross-functional collaboration and shape overall company direction. Attendees will gain insights into breaking down operational silos, aligning goals across departments like IT, operations, HR, and marketing, and utilising technology to enable real-time data sharing and visibility.

The corporate roadmap to payment excellence: Keeping pace with emerging trends to maximise growth opportunities
In today's rapidly evolving finance and accounting landscape, one of the biggest challenges organisations face is attracting and retaining top talent. As automation and AI revolutionise the profession, finance teams require new skillsets centred on analysis, collaboration, and strategic thinking to drive sustainable competitive advantage.